Food Additives: A “Gummy” Subject

By
 Maryam Jawid

Today’s modern human diet poses a stark contrast to that of just a few hundred years ago. Large scale factory food production and processing have permanently altered the way the world perceives food. Even health conscious consumers selecting items labeled “paleo” or “all natural” encounter baffling product ingredient lineups longer than a weekly grocery list. While consumers frequently eschew substances such as monosodium glutamate (MSG) and high fructose corn syrup, three equally common, foreign substances that pervade food labels include xanthan gum, guar gum, and sodium benzoate. So, what really are these additives, and do they pose health risks?

What Are Food Additives?

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) defines food additives as any food component not attributed to the food itself, including indirect and direct additives. While packaging and processing procedures may produce the former in trace amounts, direct food additives include any substances introduced into comestibles for a specific purpose, such as improving production, processing, packaging, flavor, freshness, and more. Of note, the FDA acknowledges that only “most direct food additives are identified on food labels.”

The FDA does regulate food additive safety, but admits that it can “never be absolutely certain of the absence of any risk from the use of any substance.” Even the widely denounced flavor enhancer MSG, which the Mayo Clinic acknowledges at a minimum may cause headaches, nausea, chest pain, and other ills, holds FDA approval and GRAS (generally recognized as safe) status, eliciting concerns regarding the organization’s regulatory practices.

Xanthan gum, guar gum, and sodium benzoate all hold FDA GRAS status, but definitively ascertaining whether their consumption is prudent warrants a deeper investigation exploring today’s existing research.

The Gums: Xanthan and Guar

Xanthan and guar gum serve similar purposes: food emulsification (helping fats mix evenly), stabilization, and texture enhancement via their absorbent nature and food-thickening abilities. They also possess similar chemical compositions; both are polysaccharides (long chains of simple sugar molecules).

Foods most often containing these gums include sauces, plant-based milks, juices, and packaged baked goods (cookies, breads, etc.), especially gluten-free options.

While cooking and baking enthusiasts might use these gums interchangeably, their origins are distinct. The nonpathogenic bacterium Xanthomonas campestris produces xanthan gum when it ferments simple sugars or starches. Dissimilarly, manufacturers extract guar gum from Cyamopsis tetragonoloba (a legume) seeds.

To create the finalized products, xanthan and guar gum powders, from these living origins requires extensive processing. Do such manufacturing procedures render these additives unwholesome and mandate their avoidance? The science elucidates.

Examining the Science: Xanthan and Guar Gum

Government agencies do not provide a defined xanthan and guar gum ADI (acceptable daily intake). Multiple studies have involved human subjects consuming as much as fifteen grams per day without negative effects. This does not reflect “normal” intake, however, as common foods including gums, such as baked snacks or processed beverages, contain less than 0.35% to 1% gum by weight or approximately one gram. Unfortunately, no studies exist evaluating long-term, low dose gum intake that more accurately reflects typical consumer consumption.

Therapeutic Uses: Xanthan and Guar Gum

While xanthan and guar gum are more commonly considered food enhancers, these substances have also been investigated therapeutically regarding their ability to promote healthy cholesterol levels, bolster satiety, and help manage blood sugar. Although, achieving healing effects generally requires high dosages.

When a Food Additives and Contaminants study fed five men approximately ten grams of xanthan gum daily (a large quantity) for twenty-three days, their total blood cholesterol levels significantly reduced by 10%.

Further, Bioscience, Biotechnology, and Biochemistry published an article demonstrating that healthy rats fed xanthan and guar gum for two weeks exhibited significantly lowered total and LDL cholesterol levels. Additionally, diabetic rats fed the same mixture for four weeks showed substantially lowered triacylglycerol levels (another marker of unhealthy high cholesterol). Of note, these results may not apply to humans, as rat diets included more than ten times the upper limit of human gum consumption.

Regarding satiety, the research provides inconsistent results. A study published in the British Journal of Nutrition concluded that ingesting six grams per day of guar gum may aid satiety in both the immediate and long term, and also assist weight loss by preventing snacking. Still, Bioactive Carbohydrates and Dietary Fiber found opposing results. When twenty healthy men drank apple juice containing similar quantities of added guar and xanthan gum, their blood glucose, insulin levels, and satiety were no different than those of men imbibing normal juice.

The Downsides: Xanthan and Guar Gum

Although the aforementioned beneficial uses might paint the gums as healthful, arguably more substantial downsides exist, including gastrointestinal problems, microbiome disruption, and chemical cross-contamination.

At their essence, xanthan and guar gum are indigestible fibers. Thus, they may cause flatulence, bloating, and even diarrhea. Xanthan gum is even cited by researchers as “a highly efficient laxative.”

Turning attention to the microbiome and gut health, a study published in Research in Veterinary Science evokes concerns. Researchers fed young pigs infected with a pathogenic E. coli strain either plain rice or rice containing 10% guar gum by weight. The latter portion represents an extremely high gum content, but the study’s results are still noteworthy. Pathogenic E. coli proliferated far more abundantly within the pigs’ intestines among those that ate guar-gum-infused rice versus plain. Additionally, the guar-gum-fed pigs gained less weight overall (a negative effect since the pigs were still growing), but developed heavier, enlarged colons that suggested gastrointestinal dysfunction and dysbiosis (an intestinal imbalance between healthy and pathogenic bacteria). 

Beyond these potential side effects, processing procedures may introduce chemical cross-contamination. As previously mentioned, a bacterium produces xanthan gum via fermenting carbohydrates. Often, wheat or corn acts as the chosen starch medium. Although most producers label their gums “gluten free,” individuals demonstrating gluten sensitivity, such as those with celiac disease (an autoimmune gluten allergy), should exercise caution. No existing studies have definitively exposed gluten-contaminated xanthan gum, but since its production could employ gluten-rich wheat, the possibility of contamination exists.

Legume-derived guar gum merits consideration too, since legumes contain lectins and phytates, both inflammatory molecules linked to gut issues, headaches, and more. Especially relevant, seeds contain high lectin concentrations, and guar gum is seed-derived. No research currently explores whether these lectins directly cause negative side effects, but the possibility seems probable.

Moreover, dioxins (chemicals defined by the World Health Organization as highly toxic and potentially linked to reproductive and developmental problems, damage to the immune system, hormone disruption, and some cancers) pollute some guar gum. In 2008, the European Union laboratory analyzed Indian guar gum (80% of the world’s guar gum) and found dioxin concentrations 1000 times greater than the acceptable levels.

The Bigger Question: Processing

The gums may hold some therapeutic value, but generally only via immense quantities that also pose potential health risks, such as bloating and dysbiosis. Most imperative, these food enhancers are highly processed and therefore unnatural.

Revisiting xanthan gum’s processing procedures, scientists induce a bacterium to ferment carbohydrates (usually corn or wheat) that then produces a slime-like gel product that manufacturers compress, sterilize, separate via mixing with isopropyl alcohol and finally grind and package. The result is a colorless, scentless additive.

Guar gum follows a similar process, but starts with highly processed guar splits, the remnants after manufacturers remove the endosperm, husk, and germ (major plant components) from the Cyamopsis tetragonoloba (guar) seed.

These additives do not fit optimal nutritional principles, including whole, unprocessed foods and diets most aligned with ancestral eating patterns, which included predominantly tubers, plants, and animals. These aliments have fit human biology for many millennia, while today’s recent farming and industrialized food processing practices pose stark contrasts. The result?—a disconnect between what the human body craves, and what the modern human consumes. As processed foods have become increasingly ubiquitous, disease and ill health have simultaneously followed suit. Even based upon concrete research, straying from ancestral dietary principles likely interferes with attaining abundant health. Thus, eating heavily processed gums and other additives can compromise well-being.

Existing research makes it even clearer. After reviewing numerous studies, researchers concluded that nearly all food processing reduces a food’s nutritional value and often oxidizes fat molecules (chemically changes the fat molecules resulting in different, unnatural structures). Food and Chemical Toxicology linked fat oxidation to cancer, brain-degenerative disorders, and overall inflammatory reactions.

Sodium Benzoate

Sodium benzoate represents an entirely different food additive category: preservatives. Despite its prevalence, it is unfamiliar to most consumers. Typical foods containing sodium benzoate include soft drinks, sauces, condiments, and bottled, non-100% juice concoctions.

This preservative does not occur naturally, and is instead highly processed and laboratory synthesized from two chemical compounds—benzoic acid and sodium hydroxide. While most benzoic acid used to create sodium benzoate is laboratory-derived, benzoic acid does occur naturally in berries, tomatoes, and certain spices. On the other hand, sodium hydroxide is strictly a laboratory-synthesized chemical. It is an ingredient in most drain cleaners and soaps and demonstrates highly caustic and flammable properties.

The FDA recognizes sodium benzoate as GRAS (at a maximum of 0.1% concentration in foods and an ADI of five milligrams per kilogram of bodyweight per day). Still, the science supports consumers exercising caution.

The Science: Sodium Benzoate

Sodium benzoate has been investigated therapeutically regarding urea cycle disorders and multiple sclerosis (MS). A few potential positive applications have been elucidated, though these required ingesting far greater quantities than the FDA specified ADI. Research suggesting this additive poses a health threat, however, is prevalent.

Therapeutic Uses: Sodium Benzoate 

Sodium benzoate is commonly used to treat urea cycle disorders (problems excreting degraded products from protein consumption). A Gastroenterology and Hepatology review concluded that the additive represents a plausible adjunctive therapy for hepatic encephalopathy, a serious neurological disorder attributed to urea cycle dysfunction and other liver complications. Patients consumed more than ten times the ADI to achieve these results.

Clinically administered sodium benzoate may potentially help to treat MS as well. Neurochemistry Research found that in the laboratory setting, growing human brain cells in the preservative’s presence significantly augmented CNTF (a molecule important to prevent MS) production. Moreover, mouse brain cells incubated with sodium benzoate produced fewer inflammatory molecules, which may help thwart MS development. In both studies though, researchers noted a need for additional research and that downsides do exist, such as the requisite high doses to produce the observed outcomes.

The Downsides: Sodium Benzoate

First, consumers can easily overconsume sodium benzoate considering its pervasive use among food manufacturers. Additionally, multiple studies link the additive to neurological dysfunction, such as impaired memory and even attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), negative DNA alterations, and microbiome disruptions.

Exceeding the sodium benzoate ADI occurs commonly, especially in children due to their lower bodyweight. For example, a child weighing less than 84 lbs. who consumes two soda bottles and a portion of jam and ketchup exceeds the ADI. Even the average adult ingests 1.4 times the recommended limit.

Beyond dosage, its neurological effects raise major issues. Biochemical and Molecular Toxicology published findings that even low sodium benzoate concentrations impaired mouse memory and motor coordination after only four weeks. Additionally, the preservative decreased brain glutathione levels (an important antioxidant that aids in preventing brain damage). An African Journal of Biotechnology review examined this idea further, scrutinizing several studies that evaluated ADHD and hyperactivity symptoms among children. The authors concluded that surpassing the five milligrams per kilogram ADI (considered a common occurrence) provoked said symptoms.

A cell-based study from BioMed Research International evinces that sodium benzoate affects more than the brain. The researchers discovered that human lymphocyte cells (a type of white blood cell) treated with small amounts of the preservative exhibited DNA mutations that fostered cell abnormalities, malfunction, and even death. A Food and Chemical Toxicology lymphocyte study revealed similar results. Low sodium benzoate doses stimulated DNA breakage and mutation. The researchers recognized that while further investigation is necessary, at least within an in vitro (laboratory cell-based) environment, this additive can cause significant DNA damage.

This preservative also appears to affect the gut. An in vitro study from Folia Microbiologica concluded that common food additives, including sodium benzoate, can greatly decrease the beneficial and anti-inflammatory microbiome bacterial species L. paracasei. Additionally, research in Molecular Genetics and Metabolism found that when obese humans ingested the additive, their anthranilic acid levels (a marker of liver failure) surged. Gut microbes normally break down and remove anthranilic acid, so researchers hypothesized that sodium benzoate may have altered the subjects’ intestinal bacteria, inducing impaired anthranilic acid metabolism and potential liver complications. Note that both studies employed sodium benzoate concentrations that modeled average adult consumption.

The Bottom Line

Additive-containing foods are ubiquitous in modern life and often highly palatable as well as convenient. Still, science indicates that ingesting xanthan and guar gum and sodium benzoate does not help to achieve optimal health. The bottom line?—avoid food additives.

Medically Reviewed: Meaning, Purpose, and Intent
THE provides research-based, leading-edge health and wellness news and insights to help readers prevent and reverse chronic and acute maladies so as to live a disease-free, vital life. To that end, original content is medically reviewed by a medical (MD or DO) or naturopathic doctor (ND, NMD, or DNM) or a doctor of philosophy (PhD) for authenticity, validity, and accuracy, ensuring that THE’s content reflects relevant and reliable information. Please click the Medical Reviewer’s name to review his/her credentials.

Larry

Jameelah A. Melton, MD, MBA

Jameelah is a physician entrepreneur who is committed to developing innovations that improve healthcare access. She currently works with Anthem’s health management team to support clinical care initiatives. Prior to this role, Jameelah served as a medical director and consulting strategist several for digital health companies including TouchCare, backed by Fortress and Echo Health, and ODH, part of Otsuka Holding’s portfolio. Her work in health care innovation includes founding a pediatric direct primary care hybrid practice, telehealth initiatives, care management application development, and analytics. Dr. Melton’s passion for creating change within healthcare stems from her work as a practicing pediatrician in North Carolina. While caring for patients, she saw opportunities for lean care and technology to re-establish connections with patients in a way that could improve their health. Since 2012, she has been on a mission to develop services and applications that achieve these ends.

Dr. Melton’s educational background includes undergraduate and medical degrees from UNC-Chapel Hill and East Carolina University. She completed her pediatric residency training at Duke University. Jameelah also holds an MBA from Duke’s Fuqua School of Business where she concentrated in health sector management.

Maryam Jawid
Maryam Jawid holds a double Bachelor’s of Science in Nutritional Biochemistry and Public Health. She has conducted research to understand the relationship between diet, exercise, and the microbiome. Through her writing, Maryam aims to spread relevant, science-backed information that empowers readers to reach their best health.

Leave a Reply

More from Food & Diet

6 Reasons to Eat or Supplement with Turmeric

6 Reasons to Eat or Supplement with Turmeric

This mustard yellow herb contains bioactive compounds that have powerful medicinal properties used for thousands of years in India. The research you’ll find turmeric mostly focuses on its antioxidant or anti-inflammatory properties due to the main ingredient, curcumin, but there’s much more to this member of the ginger family.

Eat Better, Eat Less Pizza

Eat Better, Eat Less Pizza

Nobody thinks of pizza as a health food. But not many know just how unhealthy pizza can be.

“Not only is pizza one of the things children and teens eat most often, it is packing on extra calories, extra fat, and extra sodium, or salt,” said Lisa M. Powell, Ph.D., professor of Health Policy and Administration at the School of Public Health at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

The So-Called “Healthy” Foods That Disrupt Blood Sugar + Slow Metabolism

The So-Called “Healthy” Foods That Disrupt Blood Sugar + Slow Metabolism

Metabolism is the complex process of transforming food into energy. Every time you eat, your body decides what must be transformed into immediate fuel, what gets shelved for easy access, and what goes into long-term storage. This is how your body keeps you and your biochemistry moving along through life. Ideally, this should work smoothly, but . . .

Goitrogens

Are Dietary Goitrogens Really Something to Avoid?

Broccoli, kale, and other members of the cruciferous vegetable family frequently get placed in the superfood category, but if you look a little closer, you may find some people suggest we avoid these foods. The reason? Compounds known as goitrogens.

Are they so harmful you should avoid these healthy, green foods? Let’s see what the literature has to say.

Top 5 Maca Root Benefits and Nutrition (No. 4 is Best)

Top 5 Maca Root Benefits and Nutrition (No. 4 is Best)

Despite being revered for its medicinal properties for thousands of years, maca root is one of the newest remedies to take center stage in the natural health community, and its newfound superfood status is well-deserved. Researchers are continually turning up new health benefits associated with this powerful root vegetable.

What is maca? Known by its scientific name, Lepidium meyenii, maca is a type of cruciferous vegetable . . .

Keto Diet Food List, Including Best Keto Foods vs. Worst

Keto Diet Food List, Including Best Keto Foods vs. Worst

The ketogenic (or “keto”) diet is a very high-fat, very low-carb diet that has gained tons of attention lately for its weight loss benefits. The goal of the keto diet is to enter and then stay in a metabolic state called ketosis, in which you burn fat for energy, rather than carbohydrates (glucose).

In the typical diet, our bodies (brains and muscles) are fueled by glucose (a type of sugar) that we get from eating carbohydrate foods. But if those carbs stop coming in and glucose levels drop . . .

4 Reasons to Reach for Sweet Cherries When Coping with Stress

4 Reasons to Reach for Sweet Cherries When Coping with Stress

We are a stress-obsessed society. . . . And prolonged stress has been proven to do a number on our health. In fact, chronic stress can often leave us addicted to sugar and caffeine, with elevated blood pressure, inflammation, fatigue, irregular sleep patterns, and more.

[O]ne of the biggest ways to fight stress, is with a healthy, nutrient-dense diet. And one of my favorite foods to incorporate into my diet is sweet Northwest-grown cherries.

Tap Water Toxicity: Widespread Contamination Impacting Millions

Tap Water Toxicity: Widespread Contamination Impacting Millions

Just because your tap water meets federal safety guidelines doesn’t mean it’s actually safe to drink, according to a first-of-its-kind analysis and user-friendly database. Using data from municipal water supplies all over the United States, Environmental Working Group found widespread tap water toxicity, including known and suspected cancer causers.

Canola Oil Debate

Canola Oil Debate

While fats were once blacklisted, we now recognize the benefits of consuming healthy fats as part of a balanced diet. However, there remains some debate over which fats deserve the designation of “healthy.” There’s a general agreement about some fats belonging to the healthy category, such as olive oil and fish oil, and others to the unhealthy side, such as trans fat.

Some other fats are still hotly debated . . .

Goat Milk Benefits Are Superior to Cow Milk

Goat Milk Benefits Are Superior to Cow Milk

For many, cow milk is completely out of the question. It’s difficult to digest, high in allergens and loaded with lactose that can wreak havoc on your gastrointestinal tract. Enter goat milk, a nutrient-rich alternative that’s tasty, easy on the gut and far less inflammatory than regular cow’s milk.


Most Popular Articles


Most Popular Videos